Midweek Update
- The Wall Street Journal reports,
- “UnitedHealth Group’s annual investor day began much like any other corporate event. There was breakfast and then around 8 a.m. Wednesday the collection of investors, executives and Wall Street analysts filed into a capacious third-floor ballroom at the Hilton Hotel in Midtown Manhattan to hear upbeat presentations about the company’s future.
- “Unbeknown to them, one of the company’s top executives had been killed earlier that morning on the street below in what police say was a targeted attack.
- “Brian Thompson, chief executive of UnitedHealthcare, the largest U.S. health insurer, had been steps from the Hilton’s entrance at 6:44 a.m. when an assassin wearing a dark hoodie and gray backpack stepped from behind a parked car in the predawn darkness, calmly pursued him for a few steps, and then shot him with a 9-millimeter pistol.
- “Thompson staggered, appeared to turn toward his pursuer, and then collapsed. The killer fled down an alley and then escaped on a bike, according to police.”
- The FEHBlog believes the Journal’s description of the killer as an “assassin” is accurate because the press and the medical community have portrayed large health insurers and PBMs as villains. (The term “assassination” usually refers to a politically motivated murder.) This erroneous portrayal stems from the decades long feud between the medical and health insurance communities that the FEHBlog has documented. It is high time for the feud to be resolved. RIP Mr. Thomson.
From Washington, DC,
- The AP tells us that all of the House of Representatives elections have been called, and the final 2025 split is 220 Republicans and 215 Democrats.
- STAT News reports,
- “Negotiations over a large health care policy package are heating up this week as Congress hurtles toward a government funding deadline at the end of the month.
- “Congressional Republicans on Tuesday made an offer to Democrats that included a three-year extension of pandemic-era telehealth flexibilities in Medicare, some reforms in how pharmacy middlemen operate, a Medicare pay bump for doctors, funding for community health centers, and extensions of public health programs in Medicare and Medicaid, according to a copy obtained by STAT.
- “However, Republicans proposed paying for the policies with a full repeal of the Biden administration’s controversial nursing home staffing rule, which sets minimum staffing requirements. Repealing the rule would have saved the federal government $22 billion. Democrats are unwilling to repeal their own administration’s policy, so the offer is a no-go, five sources familiar with the talks told STAT.
- “Negotiations are ongoing.”
- and
- “In an unexpected move, the U.S. Patent & Trademark Office has withdrawn a controversial proposal that was designed to prevent pharmaceutical companies from abusing the patent system.
- “Specifically, the proposed rule was crafted to stem the use of so-called patent thickets, which are wielded by drug companies to delay the arrival of lower-cost generic medicines in the marketplace. Essentially, thickets are collections of numerous patents that critics contend add only incremental changes to a drug and, therefore, produce little to no additional benefit to patients.
- The American Hospital Association News informs us,
- “The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Dec. 4 announced that drug manufacturers bluebird bio, inc. (manufacturer of Lyfgenia) and Vertex Pharmaceuticals (manufacturer of Casgevy) will participate in its Cell and Gene Therapy Access Model. [Both of the drugs are “Food and Drug Administration-approved gene therapies for sickle cell disease.]
- “The voluntary model will test whether a CMS-led approach to developing and administering outcomes-based agreements for cell and gene therapies improves Medicaid beneficiaries’ health outcomes, broadens access to innovative treatment and reduces health care expenditures. The CGT Access Model launches in January, and states can choose to begin participation anytime between then and January 2026. The state application portal will also go live this month and remain open through Feb. 28, 2025. In addition, states may apply for optional model funding by Feb. 28, 2025, through the notice of funding opportunity.”
- Kevin Moss, writing in Govexec, offers last minute advice for Federal Employee Benefits Open Season which ends December 9.
From the public health and medical research front,
- During the Covid pandemic the FEHBlog’s go to columnist was David Leonhardt from the New York Times. This morning, Mr. Leonhardt wrote about the bird flu.
- Caitlin “Rivers, the Johns Hopkins epidemiologist, recently published a book on preventing outbreaks called “Crisis Averted.” In it, she argues that one of the most effective public health strategies is honesty: Experts should level with people, rather than telling selective truths intended to shape behavior in paternalistic ways (as happened during Covid).
- “When I spoke with Rivers this week, I asked for some truth telling about bird flu. “As an epidemiologist, I’m worried,” she said. “I’m not worried as a mom or a member of my community. It’s not a threat that is imminent.”
- “But H5N1 bears watching. It is changing and spreading in uncertain ways, and it already presents a threat to many animals and to people who work closely with them.”
- Well put.
- BioPharma Dive informs us,
- “Zepbound, an in-demand weight loss drug from Eli Lilly, helped people in a large clinical trial lose significantly more weight over 18 months than Novo Nordisk’s rival treatment Wegovy, results released by Lilly Wednesday show.
- “The head-to-head results are a key finding that may help Lilly wrest greater share of a pharmaceutical drug market that’s forecast to eventually exceed $100 billion in annual sales. For that reason, Lilly’s study, called SURMOUNT-5, has long been circled by investors and analysts on Wall Street as one of the year’s most important drug studies.
- “Lilly only disclosed summary data in its Wednesday statement, indicating it will share fuller findings at a medical meeting next year. According to the results Lilly made available, trial volunteers with obesity or who were overweight with related health problems lost an average of 20.2% of their bodyweight from taking Zepbound, significantly more than those who received Wegovy, who lost 13.7% on average. That translated to an average of 50 pounds lost among Zepbound-treated participants, versus 33 pounds for those on Wegovy.
- “Nearly one-third of people given Zepbound experienced weight loss of 25% or more, compared to 16% in the Wegovy group, Lilly said.
- “For both drugs, the most common side effects were gastrointestinal and, according to Lilly, generally mild to moderate in severity. Side effects are being closely watched, as commercial use of Zepbound and Wegovy has shown many people taking them later discontinue treatment.”
- Gallup lets us know,
- “Fifty-one percent of working women in the U.S. report feeling stressed a lot of the day yesterday (vs. 39% of men). Additionally, 42% of working women say their job has had a somewhat or extremely negative impact on their mental health over the last six months (vs. 37% of men). The consequential ripples of women’s wellbeing affect organizations as declines in wellbeing are associated with lower engagement, higher burnout and increased participation in job-seeking behaviors.” * * *
- “Programs and managers alone cannot make progress if employees do not feel that their organization has a strong culture of wellbeing. If employees doubt leadership’s commitment to wellbeing initiatives or worry about negative repercussions for accessing them, they may avoid engaging with these offerings. This avoidance can lead to resources being overlooked and employee needs remaining unmet, ultimately affecting the company’s bottom line. Building a culture of wellbeing starts with leaders demonstrating desired behaviors, fostering open communication about the importance of wellbeing, actively highlighting available resources, and making the employee experience a central focus of their organizational strategy.”
- The Washington Post relates,
- “Splash pads found in public parks across the United States are linked to thousands of cases of waterborne diseases that leave a calling card of diarrhea, fever and vomiting, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported this week.
- “More than 10,000 children became ill from 1997 to 2022 after using splash pads, and most of those outbreaks were attributed to cryptosporidium, a parasite that causes diarrhea and spreads through contaminated water.
- “No deaths were blamed on the infections, but the CDC said families need to be more vigilant about the proper use of splash pads. The agency also encouraged parents to avoid using public aquatic centers if their children have diarrhea.”
- Per MedPage Today,
- “Blocking blood flow to the site of knee arthritis can reduce pain and potentially prevent the need for knee replacement surgery, a new study says.
- “The procedure, called genicular artery embolization (GAE), improved patients’ quality of life by 87% and their pain by 71% at a one-year follow-up, researchers report.
- “Our study found that GAE can effectively reduce knee pain and improve quality of life early after the treatment, with these benefits being maintained over the long term, especially for people who haven’t had success with other treatments like physical therapy or pain medications,” said lead researcher Dr. Florian Nima Fleckenstein, an interventional radiologist at Charité – University Hospital Berlin in Germany.”
- and
- “Traces of nine essential metals and non-essential metals in urine were linked with lower cognitive performance and the risk of future dementia, a large prospective study showed.
- “The study assessed concentrations of the essential metals cobalt, copper, manganese, and zinc, and the non-essential metals arsenic, cadmium, lead, tungsten, and uranium.
- “Comparing the top and bottom percentiles of exposure to all nine metals, the hazard ratio of dementia was 1.71 (95% CI 1.24-3.89), reported Arce Domingo-Relloso, PhD, of the Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health in New York City, in JAMA Network Open.” * * *
- “Identifying modifiable risk factors and groups at higher risk for Alzheimer’s and dementia is crucial, Domingo-Relloso observed.
- “This study not only shows that exposure to metals is associated with cognitive decline, but more importantly, carrying at least one copy of the APOE4 allele could modify this association, which opens the door to the creation of early risk assessment tools based on individuals’ genetic and environmental exposure profiles,” she told MedPage Today.“
From the U.S. healthcare business front,
- The New York Times reports
- “Over 500 hospitals have closed their labor and delivery departments since 2010, according to a large new study, leaving most rural hospitals and more than a third of urban hospitals without obstetric care.
- “Those closures, the study found, were slightly offset by the opening of new units in about 130 hospitals. Even so, the share of hospitals without maternity wards increased every year, according to the study, published on Wednesday in JAMA, a prominent medical journal. Maternal deaths remained persistently high over that period, spiking during the pandemic.”
- Modern Healthcare lets us know,
- “The largest pharmacy benefit managers are heralding an era of transparency, and the demand for these new models may suggest their traditional spread pricing approach will fade.
- “Amid growing complaints and evolving market dynamics, CVS Health subsidiary CVS Caremark, UnitedHealth Group unit OptumRx and Cigna division Express Scripts — which together control nearly 60% of the market, according to the American Medical Association — are pitching customers “transparent” PBM services that promise more flexible designs, more predictable pricing and, potentially, lower costs.
- “It’s our responsibility to continue to drive and reshape the way drug pricing is in this country. Make it more transparent to make it easier to understand,” said Prem Shah, group president of CVS Health who oversees its pharmacy and PBM divisions. “This is our step and our movement to do exactly that.”
- “These transparent PBM alternatives emerged as clients demand greater insight into how their money is spent. At the same time, lawmakers have grilled PBM executives and regulators continue investigating their business practices.”
- Per Fierce Healthcare,
- “CVS Health has announced further leadership appointments as the healthcare giant navigates choppy financial waters.
- “Len Shankman will step into the role of president for pharmacy and consumer wellness, CVS announced. Shankman, who has risen up the ranks of CVS’ pharmacy division since 2002, will lead strategy for the company’s retail pharmacies and stores. * * *
- “In addition to Shankman’s appointment, CVS revealed that Lucille Accetta has been tapped as its chief pharmacy officer. In this position, she’ll lead the charge in advocating for the role of the pharmacist and in finding ways to leverage their expertise across CVS’ enterprise.”
- The AP relates,
- “Nearly three out of 10 U.S. drugstores that were open during the previous decade had closed by 2021, new research shows.
- “Black and Latino neighborhoods were most vulnerable to the retail pharmacy closures, which can chip away at already-limited care options in those communities, researchers said in a study published Tuesday in Health Affairs.
- “The trend has potentially gained momentum since the study’s timeframe, because many drugstores are still struggling. In the last three years, the major chains Walgreens and CVS have closed hundreds of additional stores, and Rite Aid shrank as it went through a bankruptcy reorganization.
- “Drugstores have been dealing with shrinking reimbursement for prescriptions, rising costs and changing customer shopping habits. The chains have been closing money-losing stores and transferring prescription files to more profitable locations.” * * *
- “The study found that more than 29% of the nearly 89,000 retail U.S. pharmacies that operated between 2010 and 2020 had closed by 2021. That amounts to more than 26,000 stores.
- “Researchers using data from the National Council for Prescription Drug Programs found that the number of U.S. pharmacies had actually increased from 2010 to 2017 because of store openings, but the pace of closings picked up starting in 2018.”